TonyTheMan's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Memory]

If only, but then again.

I'll divide my review in 2 parts, the good and the bad, because this flash deserves a pro-like review and not just a bat in the back and 'good job', because I see a bright future in this authors flash development.

Good:

- Using subtitles and a foreing language (french) really created a surrealistic feeling and it pushed the story foward with a good grip and made sure the story evolved. This is what made it nice to watch.

- Music and sound effects and the quality of them. Musics came from Lord of the Rings to Silent Hill (not sure really, and I missed the credits too because I was busy writing this as they rolled). Everything well placed etc.

- Some of the flash 'art' featured in this flash was great but not all I must say - more about that in my bad section. The backgrounds (or rooms if you wanna call em) were nicely done with a good sense in perspection, the book felt a little flat though don't you think? If you would have made it in 3D it would have been a lot better imo.

Bad:

- I must say that the characters didn't fit in the animation. They were ok, but not fitting to this movie. Maybe you need someone to help you with the art? I mean, if the flash had realistic human art the effect and overall feeling would have been dramatically raised to the roof.

- Tension. Not nesesserily a bad thing, but a 'experienced' flash prank viewer I must say I almost stopped viewing this flash because I was waiting for a scary climax all the time. There was 1 scary moment in the flash and it was in the early stage, wich wasn't too shocking so I continued viewing.

In conclusion:

I wasn't really up to view your extra footage at all, since when you actually put a end to the story, extra things don't really interest. Me at least, I can't really talk on others behalf.

Overall I loved your flash and I hope you make more of these odd and innovating flashes. So in other words thank you for submitting this flash.

I gave this flash a 'protection vote' and all 10s, because I see a talent here so sorry for you others who think we should judge the flashes by the content.

I hope you found my review helpful.
- TonyMan

Xenosteel responds:

Ah yeah I suppose If I knew a bit 3D it would help a lot with this movie, I need to look into it as a matter of fact!

True I could use a hand with drawing because my drawings do stink (in a way) I need to practice much more, and as a matter of fact, I might consider doing a remake of this movie, possibly using drawings from a pro!

Well the tension in this movie is quite different than what you were expecting I suppose, it focuses more on depth, and a different way in delivering horror

I found your review very helpful! Thank you for such an in-depth review and summary of my movie, its very kind of you! I hope to see you review my future flash movies :) and I think you’re a great reviewer!

Again, thanks!

[Anivasion]

Nice.... kinda...

Good idea to put up a team to create a flash. Takes a lot less time that way. I gotta say the best one was FrozenPhoenix or w/e, others were.... well.... blah....

Oh yeah and when you choose a scene there wont be any music if you don't choose the first scene. Yeah you forgot to add it to start again in every scene.

[I won't forget]

>_<;

I liked it. It reminded me how fun it was watching Chobits anime series, but this flash is nothing compared to it. But as a flash it reserves a little credit. Good job!

[Weaponmaster Reborn Prev.]

Ok

You could call this a 'sketch animatin' since the lines were unfinished and if they are in fact finished then... well.. you need more experience.

Process the animation frame by frame:

Add colors
Then shadows
Then shades on the character
Then Background
Then Sound effects and better music
etc.

Otherwise it was fun, nothing original though.

[PALADIN episode 2]

Make more!

Make more, that was supreme!

(thought the german words made the flash sound bad in the credits! >_>)

[Discovering Atlantis]

Artistic

Very artistic and nicely animated! Good job! No sounds and the music was not so good, but overall I liked it a lot. Thank you for submitting it.

[The Last Two Men on Earth]

R O F L

OmG hahah that was HILARIOUS! This flash will truly shake the heads and irritate those stupid homophobes !! Hahaha I can't say I loved the sounds etc. (I almost vomited) but the joke was GREAT! LOL!!!!!!

"God has a sense of humor, he created men didn't he?" - Me xD

[D-Day WW2]

Too much FPS games

Dude you've played too much FPS games :P But I liked the flash. I am a pasifist so I am all against wars, but thats IN REAL LIFE! In flash it's all okey to kill even children.

Also did I hear StarGate SG-1 the stun gun sound in the background when they entered the beach? lol *ratatatata --- ZIIIP* XD

KillMoochie responds:

no u did not hear stargate stun gun. it was bad quality bullet hitting metal which strangly sounds like the 'stargate gun'

[Penis Pie, A Porno Short.]

I knew it

I knew it when I saw the title in the portal.

By the way there was this real life news on britain that a guy BURNED his penis while trying to imitate what happened in American Pie movie. So don't try that at home boys or you will end up with a sore penis that wont function properly for the rest of your lives.

(oh yeah you can rape cold pies, thats totally ok. And yeah f*** the orphans (joke))